Humans are emotional creatures. As marketeers, it is one of the most powerful secret weapons in our toolbox and to use it successfully, all we need to do is understand our audience and know which emotions would resonate best.
When choosing brands, our decisions are often influenced more by our feelings than by logic or rational thought. Emotional marketing leverages this aspect of human nature by building campaigns that evoke specific emotions, such as joy, sadness, fear, surprise, or nostalgia.
Why use emotional marketing?
When done well, emotional marketing can be very effective. It can make businesses, products or campaigns more memorable, increase brand loyalty, and even drive consumer behaviour. However, it’s also important to use it responsibly and authentically, as audiences can react negatively to attempts to manipulate their emotions.
Here are some reasons why emotional marketing should form part of your toolkit:
Emotions drive decision making: Studies in neuroscience reveal that human emotions play a significant role in our decision-making processes. Even if we believe our decisions are driven by logic, it’s usually our feelings that lead us to act. Buying a high cost item such as a car, for example, should, in theory, be decided purely by logic and numbers. However, when consumers actually shop for a car, their decisions often hinge on emotional factors. They might be drawn to a car because it feels comfortable and spacious on the inside, or because its sleek design and brand name make them feel successful and proud.
Perhaps they’re drawn to an electric car not just because it’s cost-efficient, but because it aligns with their values and makes them feel like they’re contributing positively to the environment. In this way, emotions — sometimes subtle, sometimes not — play a crucial role in purchasing decisions.
Emotional connections lead to loyalty: When customers feel an emotional connection to a brand, they are more likely to stay loyal and continue to purchase from that brand. This emotional bond can also lead to increased customer advocacy and word-of-mouth referrals.
Emotions make brands memorable: Emotionally charged events create powerful and enduring memories. According to the Edelman Trust Barometer, 65% of people said that their buying decisions during the pandemic were hugely influenced depending upon how brands responded to it.
A great example here is the Kleenex #AllTheFeelingsCampaign, which sensitively approached the mental wellbeing of the UK. It gave away over 100,000 free three-month subscriptions to the mental health app, Calm, that provides meditations to help relieve stress – a great and effective way of acting with compassion.
Differentiates from competition: Utilising emotional marketing can help a brand stand out in a crowded marketplace. By invoking strong emotions, companies can separate themselves from competitors who may only emphasise product features and benefits.
Increases engagement: Content that triggers emotions, whether positive or negative, is more likely to be shared, liked, and commented on and this can enhance a brand’s reach and visibility.
Creates a sense of belonging: Humans have an innate desire to belong and feel part of a community. Brands can tap into this by creating a sense of community around their products or services.
A great example of this was when small restaurants and takeaways opted to support the free school meals campaign, offering out their services during the school holidays.
The campaign, which was backed by Premier League and England football start Marcus Rashford, saw thousands of news outlets publish lists of places offering free meals to youngsters, and it captured the hearts of communities and the people who were in need.
Consumers like to feel involved and see that their chosen brands are making active movements to help people in need, it makes them feel good too.
Working together
While we’re on the note of togetherness, there’s another way of achieving a similar kind of emotional marketing too. This is controversial, but what about if brands collaborate, or even help each other? An objective here would be to offer a unique and innovative product, but as we’re talking about marketing with emotion, that’s important too.
Aldi has made great strides in this collaborative style of emotional marketing. Do you remember when BrewDog and Aldi came together via Twitter about Aldi’s knock-off version of their beer? BrewDog decided to make an Aldi version of their beer, and they came to an agreement that for every case they sold they would plant a tree in the BrewDog forest. This online back-and-forth captured the interest of news outlets, but importantly BrewDog and Aldi customers. Who, in turn, were compelled to try the new product and of course be left feeling happy that they can do their bit for the environment.
More recently was the Aldi vs Marks and Spencer cake war concerning Colin and Cuthbert the caterpillar cakes. It is unclear whether the legal action launched by M&S against Aldi was real or a genious piece of collaborative emotional marketing, but it certainly captured the attention of caterpillar cake lovers everywhere as the #freecuthbert campaign spread like wildfire across social media and news outlets.
Negative implications of emotional marketing
When done well, emotional marketing can be extremely effective, but it can also backfire if not executed thoughtfully and authentically.
Consumers are savvy and can easily detect when emotions are being manipulated in a way that feels inauthentic or exploitative.
An example of this is the 2017 Pepsi ad featuring Kendall Jenner. The ad attempted to evoke a sense of unity and positive change by referencing protest movements, but it was seen as trivialising serious social issues for commercial gain. The backlash was swift and intense, leading Pepsi to pull the ad and issue an apology.
Emotional marketing can also fall flat when it is out of touch with the audience’s feelings. In 2020, Burger King UK’s International Women’s Day campaign used a tweet that started with “Women belong in the kitchen.” Although the rest of the thread spoke about gender imbalance in professional kitchens and announced a new scholarship program for female chefs, the initial tweet was perceived as offensive and sexist, leading to an eventual apology from the brand.
While using negative emotions like fear or sadness can be impactful, they can also associate the brand with negative feelings, which is a risky strategy. In the 1980s, a series of ads for the drug prevention campaign “This Is Your Brain on Drugs” used shock tactics to dissuade drug use. While memorable, studies found that the ads had minimal impact on altering behaviour and in some cases, sparked curiosity rather than deterrence.
These examples underscore the importance of careful, thoughtful execution in emotional marketing.
It’s crucial to remain sensitive to societal contexts, understand your audience’s perspectives, and maintain authenticity in your messaging. When done poorly, emotional marketing can harm a brand’s reputation and cause a loss of consumer trust.
If you want a helping paw in creating your emotional marketing content to help promote your charity initiative or brand collaboration, throw us a bone at info@harveyandhugo.com or call 01325 486666.